Before we begin, let me say that I have great respect for both Dr. Carter and Dr. Sarfati. Their painstaking work against Evolution is quite admirable. I also appreciate their devotion to the Bible as the inerrant word of God. I recently corresponded with Dr. Sarfati regarding Creationism in my association with the Kolber Center for the Study of Creation At the same time, I must also say that, although Dr. Carter and Dr. Sarfati are experts in their respective fields of marine biology and chemistry, their grasp of the issues surrounding Geocentrism are not on the expert level. At many places in their paper I could only conclude that either Dr. Carter and Dr. Sarfati were ignorant of the details of the geocentric model or were misrepresenting it. In either case, it is my considered opinion that they are lacking the needed information they need to make an intelligent decision about this issue.
